Document and Evidence-Based Analyses of the Narrations Regarding the “Immunity from the Afterlife Account of the Buried and the Deceased in the Haramain” in Imamia Sources

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor of Quran & Hadith Sciences, Azarbaijan Shahid Madani University, Tabriz, Iran.

2 PhD Student of Quran & Hadith Sciences, Allameh Tabatabaei University, Tehran; Iran.

10.30497/qhs.2024.246056.3936

Abstract

In the narrative books of Imamiyah, there are narrations that prove certain immunities in the Afterlife in terms of punishment and reckoning for the deceased and the buried in the Haramain. Some of these hadiths have called the infidels subject to this ruling also. The conflict of these narrations with the verses and narrations that consider man responsible for his own actions and beliefs and negate any injustice in the account, and their incompatibility with the religious knowledge derived from reason, at least has brought about the hypothesis of the weakness of a part of these narrations; and this has caused the formation of this research based on the documentary and content evaluation of these narrations. According to this research, most of these narrations are weak in terms of documentation; and the apparent themes of some of these narrations are not acceptable due to their conflict with certain religious evidences. Only by interpreting the narrations and deviating from their contexts, an acceptable version of them can be rendered.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

The Holy Qur'an.
Ibn Abi Al-jomhur, Muhammad Ibn Zayn Al-Din, (1405q), Awali Al-Laali Al-Aziziyat Fi Al-Ahadith Al-Diniyat, Qom: Sayyed Al-Shohadaa.
Ibn babewayh, Muhammad Ibn Ali, (1413q), Man La Yahzoroh Al-Faqih, researched by Ali Akbar Ghaffari, Qom: Howzeye Elmiyah.
Ibn Shazan Al-Qomi, Shazan Ibn Jabraail, (1363sh), Alfazael, Qom: Razi.
Ibn shahr Ashoub, Muhammad Ibn Ali, (1380q), Ma’aalem Al-Aolamaa, Najaf: Maktabat Al-Haydariyah.
Ibn Ghazaeri, Ahmad Ibn Al-Hossein, (1422q), Al-Rijal, researched by Muhammad Reza Hosseini Jalali, Qom: Howzeye Elmiyeh.
Ibn Qulawayh, Jaafar Ibn Muhammad, (1356sh) Kamel Al-Ziyarat, researched by Abd Al-Hossin Amini, Najaf: Dar Al-Mortazawiyah.
Ardebili, Muhammad Ibn Ali, (1403q), Jamea Al-Rowat, Beirut: Dar Al-Azwaa.
Afandi, Abd-Allah Ibn Aisa Beig, (1431q), Riaz Al-Aolamaa Wa Hiaz Al-Fozalaa, researched by Ahmad Hosseini Ashkouri, Beirut: Moassesat Al-Tarikh Al-Arabi.
Barqi, Ahmad Ibn Muhammad Ibn Khaled, (1371sh), Qom: Dar Al-Kotob Al-Eslamiyah.
Bayzawi, Abd-Allah Ibn Aomar, (1418q), Anwar Al-Tanzil Wa Asrar Al-Taawil, researched by Muhammad Abd-Al-Rahman Maraashli, Beirut: Dar Whyaa Al-Torath Al-Arabi.
Pakatchi, Ahmad, (1393sh), Fiqh Al-Hadith, Tehran: Imam Sadiq University.
Poper, Karel Dimond, (1397sh), Ostoureye Chaharchoub, Translated by Ali Paya, Tehran: Nashre No.
Taqi Al-Din Helli, Hasan Ibn Ali, (1342sh), Al-Rijal, researched by Kazem Miamavi, Tehran: Tehran University.
Horr Aameli, Muhammad Ibn Hasan, (1409q), Wasaael Al-Shiaa, Qom: Moaassesat Aal Al-bayt.
Horr Aameli, Muhammad Ibn Hasan, (1412q), Hidayat Al-Ummat Ela Ahkam Al-Aemmah, Mashhad: Astan Qods Razavi.
Hosseini Helli, Hosein Ibn Kamal Al-Din, (1428q), ZobDat Al-Aqwal Fi Kholasat Al-rijal, Qom: Dar Al-Hadith.
Helli, Hasan Ibn Yousef, (1402q), Rijal Allamat Al-Helli, researched by Muhammad Sadiq Bahr Al-Aolum, Qom: Sharif Al-Razi.
Khoyi, Abu Al-Qasem, (1413q), Moajam Al-rijal Al-Hadith, Qom: Markaz Nashr Al-Thaqafat Al-Islamiyat Fi Al-Aalam.
Shobayri Zanjani, Sayyed musa, (1377sh), Kitab Al-Nikah, Qom: Sharif Al_Razi.
Tabatabayi, Sayyed Muhammad Hossein, (1390q), Al-Mizan Fi Tafsir Al-Qoran, Beirut: Moassesat Al-Aalami Le_Almatbuaat.
Tusi, Muhammad Ibn Al-Hasan, (1407q), Tahzib Al-Ahkam, Tehran: Dar Al-Kotob Al-Islamiyah.
Tusi, Muhammad Ibn Al-Hasan, (1420q), Fehrest Kotob Al-Shiaah, Qom: Maktabat Al-Mohaqqeq Tabatabayi.
Tusi, Muhammad Ibn Al-Hasan, (1427q), Rijal Al-Tusi, researched by Jawad Qayyumi Wsfahani, Qom: Howzeye Elmiye.
Fakhr Razi, Muhammad Ibn Aomar, (1413q), Eateqadat Feraq Al-Muslemin Wa Al-Mushrekin, researched by Muhammad Zaynhm, Qaherah: Maktabat Madbuli.
Fakhr Razi, Muhammad Ibn Aomar, (1420q), Mafatih Al-GHayb, Beirut: Dar Ehyaa Al-turath Al-Aarabi.
Fayz Kashani, Muhammad Ibn Shah Mortaza, (1415q), Tafsir Al-Safi, researched by Aalami, Tehran: Maktabat Al-Sadr.
Fayz Kashani, Muhammad Ibn Shah Mortaza, (1406q), Al-Wafi, Isfahan: Amir Al-Muamenin Library.
Qotb Al-Din Rawamdi, Saaid Ibn Hebat-Allah, (1407q), Salwat Al-Hazin, Qom: Imam Mahdi School.
Qohpaiy, Aenayat-Allah, (1364sh), Majmaa Al-Rijal, Qom: Esmaailian.
Kashshi, Muhammad Ibn Aomar, (1404q), Ekhtiar Maarefat Al-Rijal, Qom: Moasseat Al Al-Bait.
Kolaini, Muhammad Ibn Yaaqub, (1407q), Al-Kafi, Tehran: Dar Al-Kotob Al-Islamiyah.
Mamqani, Abdollah, (1431q), Tanqih Al-Maqal Fi Aelm Al-Rijal, Qom: Moasseat Al Al-Bait.
Majlesi, Muhammad Baqer, (1403q), Behar Al-Anwar, Beirut: Dar Ehyaa Al-Torath Al-Aarabi.
Majlesi, Muhammad Baqer, (1404q), Meraat Al-Aoqul Fi Sharh Akhbar Al Al-Rasul, researched by Hashem Rasuli Mahallati, Tehran: Dar Al-Kotob Al-Islamiyah.
Majlesi, Muhammad Baqer, (1406q), Malaz Al-Akhyar Fi Fahm Tahzib Al-Akhbar, researched by Mahdi Rajaei, Qom: Ayat-Allah Maraashi Najafi Library.
Majlesi, Muhammad Taqi, (1414q), Lawamea Sahebqerani, Qom: Esmaailian.
Majlesi, Muhammad Taqi, (1406q), Rawzat Al-Mottaqin Fi Sharh Man La Yahzoroh Al-Faqih, Qom: Kushanbur.
Najashi, Ahmad Ibn Ali, (1365sh), Rijal Al-Najashi, researched by Musa Shobayri Zanjani, Qom: Howzeye Aelmiyeh.
Namazi Shahrudi, Ali, (1365sh), Mostadrakat Aelm Rijal Al-Hadith, Tehran: Son of the writer.
Bradley, F. H. (1914). Essays on Truth and Reality. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Young, James O., "The Coherence Theory of Truth", The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2018 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), URL=https://plato.stanford.edu /archives /fall2018/ entries /truth-coherence/.
Quran and Hadith Studies‎
Volume 18, Issue 1 - Serial Number 35
Autumn 2024 & Winter 2025
September 2024

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics