Quran and Hadith Studies‎

The Dating of the Narrative Indicating the Punishment of the Apostate by the Order of Imam Ali (PBUH) in the Sources of the Fariqin; with Method of Determining the Common Ring

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Humanities faculty,Arak university , Arak , Iran

2 Doctor student of theology – Quranic and Hadith Hadith Sciences. Faculth of Humanities. Arak University. Arak. Iran.

10.30497/qhs.2025.246024.3932

Abstract

Among the important topics in Islamic jurisprudence is the discussion of apostasy rules. In many historical-narrative texts of Fariqin, there are words in which Hazrat Ali (AS) ordered to trample, kill and behead apostates in the implementation of some jurisprudence. Considering the sensitivity of the subject and with the aim of analyzing doubts, this research has dated the document and the text of the narrative “He said: O servants of God, trample them, they trampled them until they died” and seeks to determine the common link of which period it considers the first origin of its origin. This article examines the existing statements based on the rules of document and text analysis from the western perspective and using the descriptive-analytical method, it has come to the conclusion that the narrations implying the trampling, killing and beating of the apostate are weak. The textual analysis is also fake due to the contradictions of the narrations with the verses, Prophetic and Alevi life, knowledge and infallibility of the Imam (peace be upon him) and the correspondence of the statements with the teachings of non-Islamic religions and the way of the Umayyad rulers.

Keywords

Main Subjects

The Holy Quran.
Aghayi, Seyed Ali, (2011), The history of Hadith based on the mixed-analysis of document-text: possibilities and limiations, SahifehMobin, 50, 101-140.
Ahmadi, Mohammad Hasan, (2018), Study of Hadith and historical linguistics, Qom: University of Qom.
Baghuy, Hossein Ibn Masud, (1403AH), A description of tradition, Beirut: al-Maktaba al-Islamieh.
Bahrami, Hamzeh Ali; Hashemi, Maryam al-Sadat, (1402AH), Analysis of Hadith on the killing of apostate considering the Salafi and Ibn Teymieh. Studies on Hadiths, 9(2), 159-183. https://doi.org/10.30479/mfh.2023.18387.2224
Beihaghi, Ahmad Ibn al-Hossein, (1424AH), The main tradition, Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Elmieh.
Belazari, Ahmad Ibn Yahya, (1417AH), Sentences from the lineages of nobles, Beirut: Dar al-Fikr.
Darghatni, Ali Ibn Omar, (1424AH), Tradition of Dar Ghatni, Beirut: Dar al-Kitab al-Elmieh.
FeizKashani, Mohammad Mohsen Ibn Shah Morteza, (1406AH), Vafi, Isfahan: Library of Imam Ali.
Gharashi, Ali Akbar, (1412AH), Depth of Quran, Tehran: Dar al-Kitab al-Islamieh.
Golpayegani, SeyedMohammadreza, (1407AH), KetabTahareh, Qom: Dar al-Quran al-Karim.
Halabi, Taghi al-Din, (1403AH), On Fiqh, Isfahan: School of Imam Ali.
Harold, Motzki, (2011), Islamic Hadith, sources and changes (translated into Farsi by MortezaKarimi Nia), Qom: Dar al-Hadith.
HorAmeli, Mohammad Ibn Hasan, (1409AH), A description of Shia means for understanding Shia issues, Qom: Al al-Beit Institute.
Hosseini, Seyed Ibrahim, (2003), Apostasy from the perspective of Islamic law philosophy, Marefat Journal, 69, 47-58.
Ibn Abd al-bar, Abu Omar, (1412AH), On knowing friends, Beirut: Dar al-Jail.
Ibn Asakir, Ali Ibn al-Hassan, (n.d.), A history of Damascus, Unknown: Dar al-Resalah.
Ibn Asir, Ali Ibn Mohammad, (1385AH), A comprehensive history, Beirut: Dar Sader.
Ibn Asir, Ali Ibn Mohammad, (1415AH), An effort into knowing the Sahabeh, Beirut: Dar-al Kitab al-Elmieh.
Ibn Babuyeh, Mohammad Ibn Ali, (1413AH), I don't know Faqih, Qom: Office of Islamic Publication.
Ibn Haban, Mohammad Ibn Habban, (2014), Trustworthy people, Heidar Abad: Ottoman Encyclopedia.
Ibn Hajar al-Asghalani, Ahmad Ibn Ali, (1326AH/1404AH), Tahzib al-Tahzib, India: Military Encyclopedia.
Ibn Hajar al-Asghalani, Ahmad Ibn Ali, (1406AH), About Tahzib, Syria: Dar al-Rashid.
Juynboll, G. H. A (1989), Some Isnad – analytical methods illustrated on the basis of aeveral womendemeaning sayings fom Hadith literature.
Khomeini, SeyedRuhollah, (2011), A description of means, Najaf: Dar al-Kitab al-Elmieh.
Khuyi, Abolghasem, (1413AH), Dictionary of men of Hadith, Unknown: Unknown.
Koleini, Mohammad Ibn Yaghub, (1407AH), Kafi, Tehran: Dar al-Kitab al-Islamieh.
Majlesi, Mohammad TaghiIbnMaghsood Ali, (1406AH), Rowzat al-Motaghin for the description of Faqih, Qom: Islamic Cultural Institute of Kooshanbor.
MajlesiDovom, Mohammad Bagher, (1404AH), Mirrors of minds in explaining the news of the prophet's family, Tehran: Dar al-Kitab al-Islamieh.
MajlesiDovom, Mohammad Bagher, (1406AH), The haven of good people in understanding the refinement of news, Qom: Library of Ayatollah MarashiNajafi.
Mamaghani, Abdollah, (1428AH), The degree of guidance in science, Qom: Dalil Ma Publication.
Mobarakfoori, Abdosalam, (1422AH), Tradition of Bokhari, Mekah: Dar al-IlmFavaed.
Motaghi Indi, Ali Ibn Hesam, (1401AH), Workers' treasure, Unknown: Institute of Resalah.
Motzki, Harald (1996), Quevadis, Hadith- ForschungEineKritischeUntersuchung von G.H.A. Juynboll:”Nafi’ mawla of Ibn ‘Umar, his position in Muslim Hadith Literature”’. Der Islam.
Motzki, Harald (1998),The prophet and the cat: on dating malik s Muwatta and legal traditions, Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam.
Mozafari, Mohammad Hossein, (1997), Religious intolerance, Tehran: Contemporary Thought.
Najashi, Ahmad Ibn Ali, (n.d.), Najashi men, Unknown: Institute of Islamic Publication.
Nasafi, Abdollah Ibn Ahmad, (n.d.), Evidence and proofs, Beirut, Dar al-Kalam al-Tayb.
Nasayi, Ahmad Ibn Shaeeb, (1421AH), Main tradition, Beirut: Resala Institute.
Nisaboori, Moslem Ibn Hejaj al-Ghashiri, (n.d.), Sahih Moslem, Beirut: Dar al-Fikr.
Parsa, Forugh, (2009), Hadith from the perspective of orientalists: analysis of Harold Motzki Hadith studies, Tehran: Al-Zahra University.
RaghebIsfahani, Hossein Ibn Mohammad, (1404AH), Notes on Quran, Tehran: Office of Book Publication.
Sabzevari, SeyedAbd al-Ali, (1413AH), Mahzab al-Ahkam, Qom: Institute of Manar.
Safavi, Mohammadreza, (2009), Translation of Quran based on Almizan, Qom: Maaref Publication.
Saheb Ibn Ibad, Ismael Ibn Ibad, (1414AH), The context of word, Beirut: World of Books.
Schacht, Joseph, (1950), The origins of Muhammadan jurisprudents, Oxford: Oxford Univerdity Press.
Schacht, Joseph, (2014), Analyzing the history of Hadith (translated into Farsi by Ali Aghayi), Tehran: Hekmat.
Serami, Seif Allah, (1997), Laws of apostasy from the perspective of Islam and human rights, Tehran: Center of Strategic Research of Presidency.
Shafei, Mohammad Ibn Edris, (1410AH), Mother, Beirut: Dar al-Marefat.
Sharif, al-Razi, Mohammad Ibn Hossein, (1414AG), Nahj al-BalaghehLelsobhi Saleh, Qom: Hejrat.
Tabari, Majmad Ibn Jarir, (1407AH), History of societies and countries, Beirut: Dar al-Kitab al-Elmieh.
Tahavi, Ahmad Ibn Mohammad, (1414AH), Description of some works, Unknown: Dar al-Kitab Al-Elmieh.
Tarmazi, Mohammad Ibn Isa, (2016), Tradition of Tarmazi, Beirut: Dar al-FikrLeltebava al-Nashrva al-Towzi.
Toosi, Mohammad Ibn al-Hasan, (1390AH), Insight into different news, Tehran: Dar al-Kitab al-Islamieh.
Toosi, Mohammad Ibn al-Hasan, (1407AH), Analysis of laws, Tehran: Dar al-Kitab al-Islamieh.
Toosi, Mohammad Ibn al-Hasan, (1414AH), Finance, Qom: Dar al-SaghafehLeltabaeva al-Nashrva al-Towzi.
Torkaman, Mohammad, (2018), Apostasy under critical analysis: a criticism of regulations and worldly works, Tehran: Kavir Publication.
Zahabi, Mohammad Ibn Ahmad, (1427AH), Biography of noble figures, Cairo: Dar al-Hadith.
Zahabi, Mohammad Ibn Ali, (1382AH), Balance of moderation, Beirut: Dar al-MarefatLeldebaeva al-Nashr.
 
Quran and Hadith Studies‎
Volume 18, Issue 2 - Serial Number 36
March 2025
Pages 49-76